Page type: lyric reference
Artist: Justin Guarini
Canonical path: /justin-guarini/one-heart-too-many
Related lyric paths: 6
Lyric guide
One Heart Too Many
Read One Heart Too Many lyrics by Justin Guarini on LyroVerse, with linked artist context and related song paths.
person
Curated by Ethan Walker
LyroVerse team
Reference snapshot
The page facts to cite before the commentary
Use this page for the lyric text, linked artist context, and any LyroVerse editor's note attached to the song. Listener comments remain user-generated and should not be treated as the primary source.
Lyrics
One Heart Too Many
The lyric stays readable and compact here; the note and related paths sit nearby so you do not lose the song while looking for context.
Ooh, whoah, oh whoah
Da daa da daa, da daa da daa, da daa da daa
Oooh
Lover, it's an endless night
and I'm alone with these regrets of hurting you
Never thought I'd be misled
And turned away from all those dreams that we once knew
It was one heart too many
Tasted love sweet as honey
But the lie playing with my mind
Turned my back on emotions
Like they were drops in the ocean
Wasted time, it's caught up in the lie
Somewhere deep inside I feel
That only time can heal this lonely need in me
Oh, someday (someday)
Somehow (somehow)
We're gonna find our way
So, dance with me again in this forgivin' rain
It was one heart too many
Tasted love sweet as honey
But the lie playing with my mind, oh no
Turned my back on emotions
Like they were drops in the ocean
Wasted time, it's caught up in a lie, oh
Everyday away from you
Tears could fill an ocean blue
Deeper waters take me to an emptiness inside
I don't wanna drown again
Take me from a loveless end
Come on baby, reach on in
You gotta rescue me, oh
(Da daa da daa) Ahh ooh
(Da daa da daa) Yeah, gotta rescue me
(Da daa da daa) Won't you please ...
(Da daa da daa) Whoah ohh, oh
(It was one heart too many) One heart too many
(Tasted love sweet as honey)
(But the lie) You're playing with my mind, oh, no
(Turned my back on emotions)
(Like they were drops in the ocean) Wasted time
Caught up in the lie
(It was one heart too many) One heart
(Tasted love sweet as honey) So sweet
(But the lie) Keep playing with my mind
Turned my back on emotions
Like they were drops in the ocean
Wasted time, it's caught up in a lie, ohh,
(It was one) One heart too many
Tasted love sweet as honey
But the lie
(Turned my back on emotions) My back on emotions
(Like they were drops in the ocean) Like they were drops in the ocean
Wasted time ....
[Fade out ...]
Quick answers
What this page can answer fast
Who performs "One Heart Too Many"?
Justin Guarini performs "One Heart Too Many", and this lyric page sits inside the Justin Guarini catalog on LyroVerse.
Are there related songs to explore after "One Heart Too Many"?
Yes. The related section below points to A Moment Like This [American Idol show version] and Be A Heartbreaker with a short reason for opening each page next.
Where can I find more songs by Justin Guarini?
Use the artist link near the top of the page or the related paths section below to keep moving through Justin Guarini's lyric pages.
Song Room
Open Song Room
Interpretations, questions, and corrections for this song
Interpretations, questions, memories, and correction notes live together here. The room stays noindex while the best insights are reviewed.
Listener comments
What people are saying
No listener comments on One Heart Too Many yet.
A strong comment here is specific: the phrase you keep hearing, the mood you come back for, or the reason this song stays in rotation.
Sign in to post the first listener note. Reporting stays open to everyone.